Where Socialism Failed

December 29, 2025

20th & 21st century

examples of socialism's

many failures

Posts on this site may contain copyrighted material, including but not limited to music clips, song lyrics, and images, the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Such material is made available for purposes such as criticism, commentary, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education, or research, in accordance with the principles of fair use under Section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Act.


20th Century Examples


Many countries experimented with socialist or communist systems (often involving central planning, state ownership of production, and suppression of markets) during the 20th century. Several experienced severe economic stagnation, humanitarian crises, or outright collapse, often attributed to inefficiencies in central planning, lack of incentives, corruption, and political repression.


- Soviet Union (1922–1991): The largest example; rapid early industrialization gave way to chronic shortages, stagnation (the "Era of Stagnation" under Brezhnev), and collapse in 1991 due to economic inefficiency, high military spending, and Gorbachev's failed reforms (perestroika and glasnost) unleashing nationalism and unrest.


- Eastern Bloc Countries (post-WWII to 1989–1991): Satellite states under Soviet influence, including East Germany (GDR), Poland, Czechoslovakia, Hungary, Romania, Bulgaria, and Albania. These regimes collapsed in the Revolutions of 1989, leading to reunification (East Germany with West Germany) or transition to market economies amid economic backwardness and public discontent.


- Yugoslavia (1945–1992): A non-aligned socialist federation that disintegrated into violent wars in the 1990s after economic crises (high debt, inflation) eroded the unifying socialist ideology.


- Cambodia under Khmer Rouge (1975–1979): Extreme agrarian socialism led to forced collectivization, famine, and the deaths of ~2 million people; ended by Vietnamese intervention.


- Maoist China (1949–1976): Policies like the Great Leap Forward caused famine (tens of millions dead) and economic chaos; post-Mao reforms introduced markets, abandoning pure socialism for growth.


- Other African and Asian examples: Ethiopia (under Mengistu, 1974–1991), Somalia (under Barre, 1969–1991), and Angola/Mozambique faced famines, civil wars, and economic failure under Marxist-Leninist regimes, often abandoning socialism in the 1990s.


21st Century Examples


Fewer full-scale attempts occurred, but notable cases involve "21st-century socialism" or continued state control.


- Venezuela (under Chávez 1999–2013 and Maduro 2013–present): Nationalization of industries, price controls, and heavy oil dependence led to hyperinflation, shortages, mass emigration (~7 million people), and humanitarian crisis. Critics blame socialist policies and mismanagement; defenders cite falling oil prices, corruption, and U.S. sanctions as exacerbating factors.


Countries That Adopted Socialism but Later Reformed or Rejected It


These nations implemented socialist policies post-WWII but faced crises and shifted toward market reforms.


- Israel (1948–1980s) — Heavy state control and labor unions led to hyperinflation and stagnation; liberalized in the 1980s–1990s for growth.


- India (1947–1991) — "Socialist" in constitution with centralized planning caused slow growth ("Hindu rate of growth"); 1991 reforms opened markets, spurring boom.


- United Kingdom (1945–1979) — Post-war nationalizations and welfare state led to stagnation and strikes ("Winter of Discontent"); Thatcher-era privatizations reversed course.

Notes on Perspective and Debate


Views on "failure" under socialism vary: Critics (e.g., Heritage Foundation sources) argue central planning inherently causes inefficiency and repression. Defenders note external factors (sanctions, oil prices) or claim these were not "true" socialism. Mixed economies with socialist elements (e.g., Nordic models) often succeed but are not pure socialism. China and Vietnam reformed with markets while retaining communist parties, achieving growth but abandoning strict socialism.


This list focuses on cases widely cited as floundering (stagnation, crises) or failing (collapse/regime change) linked to socialist systems.





Further Reading:


On Shooting Your Way Out

Posted on

Wednesday, July 31, 2024 by Douglas Wilson


There Will Be Blood

"There are two reasons why socialism results in violence. The first is the fairly obvious one, while the second takes a bit of thought to work through. The first concerns the violence that ensues during the establishment of socialism, and the second deals with the essential and permanent violence once the paradise of socialism is established and in place. The first recognizes that when the pillaging, rapine, and sharing are about to commence, the designated victims are frequently resistant. The second creates a new victim class out of some of those who had been in the forefront of the revolution.

But in either case, there will be blood. There will always be blood."



https://dougwils.com/books-and-culture/s7-engaging-the-culture/on-shooting-your-way-out.html


Share:

December 30, 2025
An Actual Experiment
December 27, 2025
Religion of Peace in the French Quarter
December 27, 2025
... neglect by design
December 27, 2025
... my heart.
December 27, 2025
Block the roads, dump the hay, make 'em feel the heat!
December 24, 2025
Through the pine and the thunder, through the wind that never dies ...
December 23, 2025
White lights glowing, gold shining through ...
December 23, 2025
Airing grievances, 'bout the pork and the mess, yeah!
December 23, 2025
Stars shine brightest in the darkest night...
December 21, 2025
Trapped in deception, losing the fight
December 19, 2025
Yeah, Right!
December 18, 2025
Something new from something old ...
December 18, 2025
One Ultrasound at a Time ...
December 17, 2025
Got the Nobel for hope in the middle of the night.
December 17, 2025
The Miraculous Christmas Truce of 1914
December 17, 2025
Enemies shake a brother's hand ...
December 17, 2025
The Mostly Peaceful President
December 14, 2025
Punchin', slappin', hair-pullin', lockin' kids – what you gonna do?
December 14, 2025
It's a gift ... and a curse.
December 14, 2025
Freedom starts the day the lie dies
December 13, 2025
The enigma wrapped in mystery
December 13, 2025
One little stain and the whole world lost its mind...
December 13, 2025
Whispered once and never again
December 11, 2025
Awakening to True Freedom
December 10, 2025
... it’s a hard, hard waking when the red pill goes down
More Posts